Sunday, February 20, 2011

Are we fatally distracted by faulty political assumptions in this post-election period?

If we are going to renew the American Dream, and make progress towards it in the political realm, we need to keep our eye on the ball, and operate from a place of political reality. Our understanding of the needs and wants of the American people must be correct. When considering compromise positions, we must have a factual perception of where the parties involved stand.  Unfortunately, in the most recent post-election environment, our politics are driven by significant misunderstandings that are keeping us from making desperately needed progress.

The following piece features two of these misunderstandings:

NationalJournal.com - The Cook Report: Hang On Tight - Friday, February 18, 2011

While the general analysis of it is interesting, there are two unfortunate assumptions which have been all too common in this recent post-election period.

1. That the focus of American's concerns is the budget deficit.

This is a misnomer, and revisionist history. All the polls both pre- and post- election revealed what Americans are really concerned about. And my personal experience talking to literally hundreds of voters over many weeks during the election can attest to it. People are concerned about jobs and the economy. Period. Health care and education are a distant second. Our wars and the budget are barely on the radar right now.

Now, we can certainly debate over whether this is what we should be most concerned about, but this conservative fantasy that somehow Americans are obsessed with cutting spending and balancing the budget asap has infected our media and public dialogue. On the contray, Americans want to see good jobs, and farbeit from anti-government on this issue, are closely divided on whether the stimulus even went far enough. We need to change the dialogue, guiding by a correct understanding of the real desires of the American people.

2. The Republicans are "good at cutting spending."

A conventional wisdom that has little basis in reality. One only has to look at the 8 years of the Bush administration for evidence to the contrary. And Republicans (generally) have never seen a defense program, a war, a corporate tax expenditure, a fossil fuel industry subsidy, or a highway funding project that they didn't like. We need to change our language to reflect reality. Only then can we have a real discussion regarding federal government expenditures and revenues, and how best to address the budget situation into the future.   For while the budget problem needs to be addressed in the long term, the short-term emergency is an unacceptably high employment rate and declining real wages. This is a problem that left unattended will destroy the middle class, and our country with it. However, the good news is, if it is properly addressed, it will go a long ways to resolving the budget deficit, as the relatively good economic times of the mid and late '90s can attest.


No comments: